Excellent and timely piece
here by El Gibbs in
New Matilda on the Federal Government's plan to set up an
Australian Charities and Not-for-Profit (NFP) Commission to improve regulation of the not-for-profit sector.
The Federal Government's l
egislation to set up up the
Australian Charities and Not-for Profit Commission to manage all aspects
of NFP governance and require annual financial reporting by organisations
across the country
went through the House of Representatives last week and is due to come before the Senate in the next sitting of Parliament.
The relevant bills have been through an extensive consultation process,
including a formal review by a Senate Committee. The Greens, who hold the balance of power in the Senate, support the legislation in broad terms, but intend to
move amendments in the
Senate and may block the legislation if t
heir amendments are not adopted.
The Opposition Liberal National Parties
currently oppose the creation of the Commission. and provided over 30 speakers against the Bill when it came before the House of Representatives last week.
As El points out the main industry bodies representing the not- for- profit sector in Australia have been calling for the streamlining and improvement of the regulation of the not- for- profit sector for some considerable time and there is widespread support for the Commission.
However, despite this level of support there remain concerns that, without support from the states and
territories, the impact of the Commission will be to increase, rather
than decrease, the administrative burden on
NFP groups, particularly smaller agencies.
I have cited El's piece in full:
Will a Charity Commission cut Red Tape
by El Gibbs
A proposal to regulate and oversee a section of the Australian
economy that employs 8 per cent of workers and comprises over 600,000
different organisations went through the House of Representatives last
week. It’s due to come before the Senate in the next sitting of
Parliament.
The proposed legislation will set up a commission to manage all aspects
of governance and require annual financial reporting by organisations
across the country.
The Australian Charities and Not-for-profit (NFP) Commission is a long-standing goal of the NFP sector and has been recommended in a series of reports into the sector since 2001. Currently, charities and NFP
groups report to a myriad of government agencies. They often have to
report a number of times and in different ways, creating a great deal of
red tape.
"We are at the altar of the reforms we want and need and we ask for the
support of our national parliament and of the states and territories to
deliver for us better and smarter regulation. We don’t want to be jilted
yet again," David Thompson AM, Director of the National Roundtable of NFP Organisations, told New Matilda.
The Commission will also oversee future changes to the definition of
what is a charity and which organisations are able to claim the
lucrative Deductible Gift Recipient (DGR)
status, that allows donations to be tax-deductible — this has an impact
on the kind of fundraising an organisation can do. The Commission could
also frame the unique place the NFP sector holds in relation to the government and business sectors.
The CEO of ACOSS, Dr Cassandra Goldie has said:
"Our sector is overly but ineffectively regulated. For the reams of
paper and hours of analysis that charities put in to reporting the same
information to multiple funders and regulators, we know little about the
activities, size or scope of this essential sector."
The proposed Commission will, according to Senator Ursula Stephens, have three main objectives.
"Its first object is to maintain, protect and enhance public trust and confidence in the NFP sector. Its second object is to support and sustain a robust, vibrant, independent and innovative NFP sector. The third object underlines the important role that the ACNC will have to promote the reduction of unnecessary regulatory obligations on the NFP sector."
In a statement from the State, Territory and National peak groups for
the sector, Goldie states that "the creation of the Australian Charities
and Not-for-profit Commission is the culmination of a long process and
has broad support from the community and social services sector.
UnitingCare Director, Lin Hatfield-Dodds, told New Matilda that the
opportunities offered by the Commission could be of great benefit to the
community and to the sector:
"It’s important that funders can quickly and easily get an objective
and transparent look at the community groups they support. The
Commission could also act as a ‘Report once, use often’ tool, so that
community groups report to one agency across all government. When we are
spending public money, we have to be transparent. However, there is a
risk that we spend more time and administration on reporting, rather
than delivering innovative services."
However, there are concerns that, without support from the states and
territories, the impact of the Commission will be to increase, rather
than decrease, the administrative burden on NFP groups. Currently, organisations can either incorporate, and be regulated by ASIC,
or form an association, which is regulated by state-based Departments
of Fair Trading. The addition of a Commission, with no corresponding
reduction in state-based regulation, is of concern to many groups. COAG is due to consider these issues early in 2013.
In the interim, the Commission could drive reform of red tape within the
federal government by streamlining reporting requirements across
departments and agencies. For example, each time a group applies for a
grant, they have to start from scratch, rather than being able to
register with the Commission once for all other agencies.
The relevant bills have been available for public scrutiny for some
months, and have been through an extensive consultation process,
including a formal review by the Senate Community Affairs Committee.
The
current legislation is the result of many changes, however there are
still concerns held by the Greens, who intend to move amendments in the
Senate in the next sitting of Parliament.
"As I outlined in my dissenting report
on this legislation, the Greens remain concerned that there’s not
enough detail about gag-clauses for advocacy groups, and we think there
needs to be more consultation on the governance arrangements and
independence for the sector to advocate on behalf of those they look
after," Greens Senator Rachel Siewert told New Matilda:
"Not-for-profit groups are an essential part of civil society and it’s
important that this legislation gives transparency in dealing with
government. We also want to see the Commissioner given more power to
drive the red-tape reduction agenda."
The Greens confirmed to New Matilda that they will consider blocking the
legislation if their amendments are not adopted by the Government.
However, they stated their commitment to working with the Government to
improve the bills to address the remaining issues of concern to the NFP sector.
The LNP currently opposes the creation of the Commission. Despite the broad sector support, the LNP
provided over 30 speakers against the Bill when it came before the
House last week. Kevin Andrews, the Shadow Minister for Families,
Housing and Human Services, stated
that "this is legislation which has been foisted upon the charitable
sector in Australia which they do not want, which there has been no case
made by the hapless minister at the table."
"This is simply not true," said Thompson, who leads the sector’s peak
body. "The evidence is in the thousands of words in submissions from the
sector, calling for this reform. The Government has taken on board a
significant number of issues raised in submissions."
Other LNP members quoted a range of charitable and NFP
groups’ concerns about the Bill. However, some of these quotes were
from submissions about a much earlier version of the legislation and
many of these concerns have now been remedied. Several sources have
confirmed that there has been considerable disquiet among those groups
named by LNP members in the debate.
One, the Australian Institute of Company Directors, is quoted
as having concerns regarding the impact of the legislation on board
members, most of whom are volunteers. In a recent statement, the AICD
said: "if suitable amendments giving effect to these changes were to be
made to the current Bill, and subsequent to our review of the revised
Bill wording, we would support its passage through Parliament." They
support the amendments that the Greens will be putting to
the legislation.
The Bill has been introduced into the Senate and is due to be debated in
the next sitting, starting 9 October. If the legislation is not passed,
Thompson says "it will be back to the drawing board in the quest to get
the regulator we want. We have waited a long time and an enormous
effort has been put in to get it this far."